User blog comment:Tayzer/New ico/@comment-4126310-20120303142915/@comment-4126310-20120304134919

I get that, but it doesn't address my point. The favicon has two roles: be unique and recognisable enough to identify a website with a single glance (I think the F does that), and represent what the website is about (it does that too, standing for "fan labor"). The FiM Wiki has Derpy because it used to be, once upon a time, a 4chan wiki, and therefore Derpy was fitting; as the role of the wiki changed, the icon stayed the same.

In either case, this is not a decision that ought to be done by three people. The priority right now should be getting more traffic, which means improving existing articles to make them more consistent, possibly adding a few more, and working on prototype pages. Everything else we can worry about later.