Talk:Nyx/@comment-3245456-20120603080742/@comment-184.162.36.48-20120618135855

I do not wish to re-ignite the original spark but since I have finished reading Past Sins a few days ago, I can say that Nyx, and when I say Nyx I mean the filly, is not a Mary Sue in all of its entirety. Yes, she does possess some kind Mary Sue-ish elements but they're the minor elements that can be easily overlooked.

However, the most Mary Sue-ish character in that story is Nightmare Moon's version of Nyx. Why? Because Nightmare Moon, being the corrupted form of Luna, is nothing more than a lingering sentiment. When you look at it, from chapter 12, I tthink that's when Nightmare Moon makes a grand comeback, to chapter 17, Nyx, when she is Nightmare Moon, is a huge Mary Sue.

Other than that, Normal Nyx is well done, though she is not perfect. That alone is able to refute some arguments about her being a total Sue. To me, she deserves my adoration and love, and for those that do not like her, well let's say that I'll love and tolerate you even if we get into a massive argument about that matter.