Forum:Guidelines

We should probably discuss the guidelines first, before we link to them. Right now, they're basically the ones from the parent wiki. Which is fine as far as it goes (though the wording will have to be adjusted), but that does have consequences. Is it consensus to keep the popularity criterion intact? This would keep out most OC ponies, but it would arguably also disqualify stuff like Humanized ponies, most comics, and lead to discussions about how derivative works should be dealt with (right now, there is a page for Cupcakes with alternate endings, but can anything be posted in that section or does every entry need to meet the criterion separately? similarly, Rainbow Dash is a show character, so does that mean everything she's in qualifies, no matter how far it is removed from the show?).-Tulipclaymore 02:50, October 18, 2011 (UTC)